Doberman vs. Rottweiler: Which is a Better Family Pet?

Aug 3, 2022 | 0 comments

Doberman vs. Rottweiler

Doberman vs. Rottweiler: Both Doberman Pinscher as well as the Rottweiler, are famous for their feared guard dogs. In recent years, humans have begun to realize they are much more affectionate than was expected. This change has resulted in increasing numbers of people choosing to adopt the Doberman or Rottweiler as pets for their families.

The Rottweiler, and the Doberman Pinscher, indeed look quite similar. However, both breeds are very different in temperament, which makes them a perfect match for various types of families.

If you’re in search of the perfect pet to add to your family, which breed of dog is best for you?

The solution to the Doberman vs. Rottweiler argument will depend on your home’s specific circumstances and the ambiance of your house.

Doberman vs Rottweiler: Breed History

Doberman Pinscher

Doberman Pinscher

The Doberman Pinscher can be traced back to a specific person, Louis Doberman. He was a tax collector, which was a dangerous job in the 19th century. He desired to have a reliable dog to keep him safe while working.

Louis was a member of the local dog shelter, which meant he was able to access many different breeds of dogs that were used to create the perfect dog.

It’s unclear which dogs were part of his original breeding program; however, it is likely to have included the Rottweiler, the German Shepherd, the German Pinscher, and The Great Dane.

Since its introduction, the Doberman is often used in the media as guard dogs, aid dogs, therapy dogs, and military and police dogs.


Rottweiler Temperament

The Rottweiler is a dog breed that dates back to Romans who accompanied the army of the past through Germany. They were primarily used for cattle herders. Later, when the Romans were forced to leave Germany in the late 1700s, they left plenty of their dogs that worked.

Rottweilers have always been working breeds, herding dogs, and guard dogs. They pulled carts too in times of need.

The Rottweiler breed of a dog almost died out in the 20th century when smaller dogs, more manageable, were able to take the place of many Rottweilers’ usual tasks.

Fortunately, a group of dedicated breeders ensured that Rottweilers survived and are today among the top adored breeds of dogs throughout the United States. They’re still utilized in certain parts of the world as herding dogs and are often found working in security.

Doberman vs Rottweiler Appearance

Doberman vs. Rottweiler

Many people are confused between the Doberman and Rottweiler despite having distinct appearances. Both breeds share identical coloring and an unpopular reputation, meaning that people often mistake the two breeds.

Doberman’s Appearance

Dobermans tend to be slim in appearance. They can attain an average height of 28” and an average weight of 60 and 90 pounds. Doberman Pinschers are a popular breed. Doberman Pinscher appears in a diverse range of shades, the most popular is black or tan; however, they can also be blue, brown, and white.

Their coats are thin, smooth, and don’t need much grooming. Dobermans shed modestly every two years as they grow their coats for the season.

Rottweiler’s Appearance

The Rottweiler is a lot more sturdy and well-built. They are bred for strength. Despite being smaller than Dobermans, they weigh significantly more.

A Rottweiler has a huge head with an oval muzzle and loose lips (that could result in some drooling). The majority of Rottweilers weigh between 95 and 130 pounds.

The beautiful dogs can only attain their full size once they’re about three years old. So don’t be concerned when you find that your Rottweiler puppy is smaller than you anticipated. They’ll soon grow and get the broad, slender chest and muscular build Rottweilers have.

Rottweiler coat is typically black and tan. However, it is also available in mahogany black and rust coats. Their fur is rough and short, and Rottweilers typically require little grooming.

Rottweiler vs Doberman Temperament

Behavior is one of the main aspects to look for when you are looking to adopt or shop for a pet. Both Rottweiler and Doberman are known as frightful, aggressive dogs that are more than just a little scary. However, often it’s not the case.

The primary factor influencing the degree of aggression will be interacting with other dogs and the constant focus on them. Dogs who are properly socialized, constantly engaged, and activities can be great companions with minimal aggression.

Doberman’s Temperament

Dobermans are extremely loyal and are often distant and suspicious of strangers. They are frightened and require some sort of job to keep them entertained. They are smart, and their owners frequently find that their dogs beat them to get more food.

Dobermans are known to be bonded with a single person. This might not be the right choice if you seek a family pet who loves everyone equally. If properly trained and socialized, these dogs will be friendly and kind to everyone, even children.

Rottweiler’s Temperament

Socialized and well-trained Rottweilers are loving and affectionate dogs, but male Rottweilers tend to be dominant and a little aggressive when it comes to other dogs. Rottweilers are bred to work and need some kind of stimulation and “job” around the house.

The Rottweiler’s temperament makes them a great pet for families, as their primary job is to protect and guard their children. They require a firm hand from the very beginning. They’re content to follow their own ideas, for instance, taking down your entire yard if bored.

Doberman vs. Rottweiler Exercise and Training Needs

Every dog needs some kind of exercise. But stressed dogs can be very destructive. Certain breeds require more activity than others. Therefore, it’s crucial to pick one suited to your way of life.

For example, runners and hikers love having companions such as Weimaraners, Vizslas, and Border Collies who can keep up with them.

The big dogs, like Dobermans and Rottweilers, are able to cause quite a bit of damage to your home, which is why it’s essential to think about whether you’re able to keep these dogs content.

Doberman Pinscher’s Exercise and Training Needs

Dobermans are active dogs who require plenty of exercises, although they are also couch potatoes when they take their daily walks. They also require a lot of mental stimulation, and without which, they may become destructive and even irritable.

It’s the reason why early socialization, as well as consistent training, is essential for Dobermans. Dobermans need to maintain this level of training throughout their life.

If you’re not interested in training your dog’s obedience, there are plenty of other enjoyable activities you can play together with your Dobie. They respond well to positive reinforcement, and they love playing with puzzles and games to complete.

They don’t need special dog guard training because it could result in an animal that is too aggressive and driven for the family.

Rottweiler’s Exercise and Training Needs

The Rottweiler requires some form of exercise for mental stimulation and to avoid becoming overweight. The breed is predisposed to obesity and can result in serious health problems in the event that it is not dealt with quickly.

Rottweilers require the early stimulation of socialization and are constantly reinforced throughout their life. They should be exposed to children, pets, and adults frequently to stop aggression issues from being developed.

A well-socialized Rottweiler is a parent who loves their children. However, they must be watched when they are part of groups since they may become excessively protective.

Rottweilers must also be provided with continuous training. They enjoy working and excel in a wide range of dog sports, such as weight pulls, herding, as well as obedience, and agility.

Rottweiler is an excellent pet for your family if they’re given something to do and are physically active and socialized regularly.

Doberman vs Rottweiler Health Problems

The truth is that all pure-bred breeds are susceptible to health issues that are unique to the species. Most breeders with a good reputation examine their dogs for genetic issues and will not offer puppies with evidence of these diseases.

But, you can be sure to see your Rottweiler and your Doberman experience health problems as they age. Always lookout for any signs of hereditary illnesses that are prevalent in this breed.

Doberman’s Health Problems

Dobermans are believed to live between 9 and 11 years. However, puppies with the appropriate treatment, nutrition, and exercise could live as teenagers. They are more likely to be affected by severe diseases like:

  • Wobbler’s disease
  • Cervical vertebral instability
  • Cardiomyopathy
  • of Willebrand’s disease
  • Osteosarcoma

Rottweiler’s Health Problems

Rottweilers can live a full life of between 8 and 12 years, which means females can live at least two years longer than males. But a few health issues can be found in the breed and other ailments seen frequently in large dogs.

The most prevalent diseases that affect Rottweilers are:

  • The elbow and hip dysplasia
  • Aortic stenosis
  • Ectropion and Entropion
  • Cruciate ligament rupture
  • Osteosarcoma

Rottweiler vs. Doberman: Which is Better for Your Family?

When it comes to deciding the best pet for you and your loved ones, there is no winner between the Rottweiler debate and the Doberman Pinscher debate.

In the end, it’s all about your family’s size, the number of kids you’ve got, the amount of time you will have with your dog, and the various options for lifestyle. Both breeds can make excellent pet companions if adequately trained and socialized.

The majority of Dobermans will be better suitable for smaller homes where they can bond with only one individual. They are safe around children; however, they are not as snuggly and secure as the Rottweiler.

Rottweilers are ideal for families with children in they can serve as protector dogs for the whole family. Both breeds require extensive training and socialization starting at the beginning to ensure they develop to be great pets for the family.

Recommended Articles